I have been taking a little art course over the past few months. It is given by the neighbor of a friend and is in the woman’s home. It has been a nice diversion, but during the past two classes I have not been thrilled with her approach to teaching. I have found her to be inconsistent and a bit scattered. I also don’t like the way she keeps drawing on everyone’s drawings. I have a drawing at home that I keep getting compliments on and I know that the crucial details are not my own and keep feeling like a fraud. Yesterday’s class took the cake, was the cherry on the sundae (trying to use food puns here!).
We were working on a still life consisiting of a vase and some fruit sitting on a table draped in fabric. Before we start in on the good paper, she has us start out with a smaller sketch, to get the proportions and placement the way we want it. So far so good.
So now we have moved on to the good paper stage. I am cruising along, sketching it in as I see it and as I did it on the practise paper. The teacher is standing behind me and then says, “Ann, it is surprising that for such a large person you are so un-generous on the paper. Look at Donna’s (another lady in the class) she is so skinny and she is using the whole page. You need to be a more generous person.”
This pissed me off on many levels:
- 1. I am a large person. I have a mirror. I don’t need you to tell me.
- 2. Size is not an indication of temperment, any more than skin color, eye color, height etc. Don’t make presumptions based on the size of my ass.
- 3. I am not un-generous.
- 4. This is how I did it in my sketch, I was centering the vase to leave room at the top for the draped fabric background. Why wasn’t something said at the sketch stage?
- 5. Why didn’t I drop this class when I thought she was just a lousy teacher?
I had a big debate with myself whether I was going to post about this. Exactly what is the function of this blog? How much to reveal, what is the purpose and who am I doing this for. I have read other’s sites where they are wondering the same thing – and honestly, the sites that do reveal the humaness of the author are the ones that touch me.
ps.I did not do the sketch that I uploaded with this post – wish I could claim it! I think she is beautiful! you can find her here