up yours Gender Genie!

Julia at Knitting History was kind enough to share this link today. It is an article in The Guardian written by Ms. Esther Addley. It speaks of the new trendiness of knitting as witnessed by various celebrity knitters. What I found most objectionable was the following:

“The emergence of knitting as an activity as attractive to men as to women may mark its final transition from a soporific time-killer favoured by elderly ladies to a respectable hobby like any other.

That someone named Esther would stereotype anything as the province of elderly ladies I find surprising. She says knitting is soporific (sleep inducing) and a time waster. Let’s give Ms. Addley the benefit of the doubt and assume that she has never tried knitting and doesn’t know how exciting and creative it can be.

That she then goes on to assert men taking up needles has moved knitting into the ‘respectable hobby’ category is downright insulting (and not just to knitters). Somehow, the presence of cajones makes knitting socially acceptable. The societal Gold Seal of Approval. Thank God for the social insight brought about by Ms. Addley’s keen powers of observation. All along I thought my biggest problem with knitting was my reluctance to swatch – here it has been my lack of scrotum!

4 thoughts on “up yours Gender Genie!

  1. Ann, you’re the best! I can’t believe when I first read that article that I overlooked that paragraph – I must have been distracted. Me, a feminist scholar, not picking up on that! I’m glad you’re watching my back :-)

    Julia

  2. Yikes! Yet another clueless journalist who fails to properly investigate a piece gives us a twisted view of knitting as a “trend”. And wasn’t knitting an activity that was practiced by men way back when? Sheesh.

  3. Three cheers for hanging Esther! I was a bit peeved when I read this too. Yes, I’m thrilled that men are comfortable enough to pick up the craft, but that in no way legitimizes it any more than it was already legit!

    What it does do is make it ok for us relegate it back to the grannies when the fad is over…that, I think, is the sum total effect of articles like that one.

    I’ll keep working on my grey hairs…

  4. What wrath and indignation your post has incurred!
    I’m with you, although I must say that I have been known to fall asleep while knittingdue to the hypnotic, meditative state it can put me in…

Leave a comment